Gypsy Roma Traveller Leeds
The permanent site of the Gypsy Roma Traveller Communities
Racism and prejudice has never been too far from Traveller and Gypsy people and you can read about the history of persecution in our History Section.
The following briefing has been supplied by Dave Cannon from ACERT especially for Travellers in Leeds website.
The past year has seen a number of important national initiatives developing. It is important that these national initiatives are supported by well informed local pressure. ACERT is issuing the following information in order to encourage its members to complement national developments by raising Traveller issues locally.
Please use this information to;
The Traveller Law Reform Bill was drafted by the Traveller Law Research Unit of Cardiff University and funded by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Traveller communities were widely consulted in the drafting process. Last year the Conservative MP David Atkinson gave the Bill its first reading (see Early Day Motion below). Amongst its many provisions it calls for;
The Traveller Law Reform Coalition consists of all the national Traveller Groups including;
The Traveller Law Reform Bill also has the support of;
This House notes that Gypsies and Travellers are one of the most excluded groups of people in the country who experience the highest infant mortality rates, the lowest life expectancy, the worst accommodation provisions, the highest illiteracy rates, the most racist press coverage which lead to the most complaints to the Commission for Racial Equality; further notes that a humane society is defined by its treatment of groups such as Travellers who have a right to a decent place to live, equal to that of the settled community; acknowledges that reported anti-social behaviour is a consequence of long term social exclusion that will not be reversed by harsher penalties but can be addressed by a responsible sites policy; urges the Government to prioritise initiatives to raise the social inclusion of the Traveller community and suggests that the Government introduce the Traveller Law Reform Bill as tabled in the last Parliamentary Session.
This was signed by the following 78 MPs;
Labour
Terry Davis Doug Naysmith Mike Hancock Harry Barnes Brian H Donohoe Edward O’Hara Evan Harris John Battle Clive Efford Linda Perham Nick Harvey Andrew Bennet Huw Edwards Ernie Ross Simon Hughes Roger Berry Bill Etherington Phil Sawford Nigel Jones Clive Betts Barbara Follett Brian Sedgemore Paul Keetch Russell Brown George Galloway Alan Simpson Paul Marsden Karen Buck Ian Gibson Marsha Singh David Rendel Martin Caton Win Griffiths Paul Stinchcombe Bob Russell Michael Clapham Kelvin Hopkins Gavin Strang Andrew Stunell Helen Clark Brian Iddon Desmond Turner Paul Tyler Ann Clwyd Piara S Khabra Rudi Vis Richard Younger-Ross Harry Cohen Andy King Mike Wood Conservative Iain Coleman Jim Knight David Wright David Atkinson Tony Colman Mark Lazarowicz Derek Wyatt John Randall Michael Connarty Tony Lloyd Liberal Democrat
Plaid Cymru
Jeremy Corbyn John McDougall Norman Baker Hywel Williams Ann Cryer John McDonnell Colin Breed
Scottish National
John Cummings Kevin McNamara Brian Cotter Pete Wishart Jim Cunningham Alan Meale Don Foster Ulster Unionist Valerie Davey Julie Morgan Andrew George Sylvia Hermon
Other support has been provided by;
Diane Abbott Tim Boswell Michael Fabricant Andrew Snell Peter Ainsworth Peter Bottomley Dominic Grieve Robert Spink Lord Avebury Annette Brooke Andrew Mackinlay Teddy Taylor Henry Bellingham John Butterfil Harry Rammell .
The All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) is a newly established parliamentary group committed to raising the social inclusion of Travellers and improving relations between Traveller and non-Traveller communities. MPs/Peers who back the group;
Labour Conservative
Diane Abbott Terry Davis Peter Ainsworth Teddy Taylor Harry Barnes Barbara Follet David Atkinson Liberal Democrat John Battle Wyn Griffiths Henry Bellingham Lord Avebury Karen Buck John McDonnell Tim Boswell Mike Hancock Martin Caton Kevin McNamara Peter Bottomley Evan Harris Michael Clapham Alan Meale John Butterfil Nick Harvey Harry Cohen Julie Morgan Dominic Grieve Andrew George Jeremy Corbyn Edward O’Hara John Randall Nigel Jones Anne Cwyd Paul Stinchcombe Robert Spink Bob Russell.
A radical overhaul of policy on unauthorised Traveller encampments was announced by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (OPDM) 5/7/02 to tackle public concern about nuisance and disorder arising from such encampments.
The Government's new strategy combines tough powers for police to move on unauthorised Traveller encampments with improved local site provisions. The range of actions include:
On the 14/7/03 Rodney Bickerstaffe, President of the Labour Campaign for Travellers' Rights hosted a meeting with Yvette Cooper MP the new minister at the ODPM with responsibility for Travellers and members of the Traveller Law Reform Coalition. The meeting was very successful and the minister expressed a desire to visit sites and meet Travellers again in the autumn.
The ODPM Select Committee for the Housing Bill has backed Travellers by calling upon the Government to introduce a statutory duty to provide/facilitate sites. Members of the Traveller community including Labour Campaign for Travellers' Rights members, Charles Smith (Gypsy Council) and Cliff Codona (National Travellers' Action Group) gave evidence to the committee.
The Traveller Law Reform Coalition organised a campaign giving evidence to the ODPM Select Committee for the Housing Bill. The CRE made a submission, which said the Bill could infringe the 1976 Race Relations Act if it did not address Traveller accommodation needs. The select committee has recommended that the government introduce a statutory duty to provide/facilitate sites within the next two years. The committee chaired by Andrew Bennett MP will make recommendations in July/September.
If the ODPM fails to include proposals to address Traveller accommodation needs, the All Party Parliamentary Group will try and amend the Housing Bill. An experienced legal firm have promised to do this.
Part 8, as it stands in September 2003, adds a new power for "the senior police officer present" to direct trespassers to leave land if;
If the people directed under this power return to any land, as trespassers, within the same local authority area, within three months of the direction, they commit an offence.
The cabinet of the Welsh Assembly will be voting on a recommendation to return a statutory duty for Traveller site provision. Kevin McNamara MP has sent letters to the First minister Rhodri Morgan and the cabinet calling upon them to support this proposal.
The Institute of Public Policy Research (IPPR) has produced a consultation paper entitled 'Moving Forward' (the final version is due to be published 18 December 2003). The consultation paper recommendations are for;
In addition, and just as importantly, service planning for mainstream activities should take account of Traveller and Gypsy needs at national and local levels. In this context local authorities must include English Romany Gypsies and Irish Travellers in the Equalities Standard as a matter of urgency. The IPPR is particularly keen to have feedback from Travellers before it agrees on a final version. This is a really important piece of research as the government will look very carefully at these proposals coming as they do from the IPPR.
Amongst other things the paper proposes the establishment of regional mechanisms to facilitate and ensure the successful establishment of new sites. It also seeks to give Traveller accommodation the same status as housing.
The report rejects the claim that the 1968 Caravan Sites' Act failed. At one point the paper declares that a statutory duty could in conjunction with the regional mechanisms proposed, give;
"a strong political message from central Government and to provide local authorities with a substantive answer to local residents who oppose provision – the need for a statutory duty might fall away if the other policy approaches are taken forward and prove successful" (Moving Forward, 2003, 10)
Traveller Law Reform Coalition and Local Government Association as well as the ODPM Select Committee now support a statutory duty. However, in the paper's final recommendations it does not call for a statutory duty. The paper however also proposes other sanctions or corrective policies that can be employed if local authorities are reluctant to implement the policies.
The paper also recommends the creation of a high powered unit in the ODPM to direct the policies proposed. Taking into account the views of the government and many Travellers, it is probably the case that there is not popular support for an Accommodation Commission and that the proposed unit will be preferable. The government was nervous because of the suggested commission's legal status and some Travellers were concerned by the Conservative MP David Atkinson's desire to give the commission investigative powers into Traveller 'anti social behaviour' arising from unauthorised encampments. Some felt this to have sinister implications.
However, in the Traveller Law Reform Bill the Commission was to be in part composed of members of the Traveller community. The proposed unit does not contain this element of inclusivity but does declare that the unit should consult Travellers.
The Local Government Association (LGA) represents all local authorities (except Parish Councils) in England, and has sibling organisations in Wales and Scotland. Its position on Accommodation for Gypsies and Travellers is that:
Travellers have been high on the agenda at the Department for Education and Skills (DfES) since the Office for Standards in Education (OFSTED) stated in 1999 that "Gypsy Travellers are the group most at risk in the education system." Since then the DfES has;
In this DfES Guide to Good Practice (issued July 2003) Stephen Twigg MP (Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Schools) states;
" All children and young people should be able to achieve their potential, whatever their ethnic and cultural background and which ever school they attend.
Working towards and achieving good practice in the education of Gypsy Traveller pupils is the responsibility of everyone within the education system – DfES, LEAs, schools, teachers, governors, the Traveller Education Support Services, parents and pupils. Many schools already have effective policies and practices in place which ensures that these children are fully integrated into school life. For others, there may be some way to go.
Schools will want to learn from what has been shown to work. This document offers advice and practical guidance on action you can take to raise the achievement of Gypsy Traveller pupils ensuring their educational and social inclusion. I hope that you will find it useful."
In the guidance the DfES makes a number of recommendations for action by LEAs and schools;
Copies of this publication (ref: DfES/0443/2003) can be obtained from:
DfES Publications,
PO Box 5050,
Sherwood Park,
Annesley,
Nottingham NG15 0DJ
0845 6022260
0845 6033360
LEA’s have a duty under Section 13 of the Education Act 1996 to secure that efficient primary, secondary and further education is available to meet the needs of the population in their area (except where responsibility for securing this falls to the further or higher education funding councils). Section 14 of the Act places LEA’s under a duty to secure that education is available for all children in their area of compulsory school –age, appropriate to their age, abilities, aptitudes and SEN. This duty applies irrespective of a child’s immigration status or rights of residence in a particular location, and would thus include children of all Travellers and displaced persons.
One of the overarching aims of the DfES is in developing an inclusive society, where everyone has an equal chance to achieve their full potential. Traveller children, in particular the highly mobile Travellers, are at risk of underachievement, and to prevent future disaffection this group need to be given speedy access to school placements. The legislation allows for there to be a limited number of exceptions to the 30 limit. For example, it permits an exception to the limit where a pupil moves into the area outside the normal admission round and there is no other school which would provide suitable education within reasonable distance of his home. In this case such a pupil can be treated as an exception to the class size limit for the remainder of that academic year. Traveller children are most likely to fall within this category.
On 24/6/02, The Diversity Directorate at New Scotland Yard hosted a conference 'Scoping London; Diversity and Travelling People in London –The Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) Approach'. The text of the presentation by Nicholas Williams has been produced. The following excerpts may be of interest;
Requests for copies should be made to;
Nicholas Williams,
Diversity Directorate DCC 4(4),
Room 910,
New Scotland Yard,
Broadway SW1H 0BG
020 7230 2697
The Race Relations (Amendment) Act came into force on 2 April 2001 and placed a general duty on public authorities to promote race equality. This general duty means that public authorities must aim to:
The statutory code of practice on the duty requires schools to have a Race Equality Policy, which is distinct from an Equal Opportunities Policy, and for the Race Equality Policy to be linked to an action plan. (CRE 2000 A Guide for Schools). Schools must assess the impact of policies, including its Race Equality Policy, on pupils, staff and parents from different racial groups and assess whether their policies have an adverse impact on the attainment of pupils from different racial groups.
The Commission for Racial Equality (CRE) is to improve its approach to Gypsy and Traveller issues. The CRE has already begun consulting Gypsies and Travellers and organisations that work with Gypsies and Travellers on ways to improve their service. A draft strategy for wider consultation should be in place by the autumn. Announcing the national initiative in Travellers’ Times, the new Commission chairman, broadcaster Trevor Phillips, revealed his personal concerns.
" Since I took up post as Chair of the CRE in March this year, I have been at pains to challenge the perception that the CRE exists solely to represent non-white communities, or rather Britain’s visible ethnic minorities. All too often, the term ‘ethnic minority’ is taken to mean someone who is black or Asian.
Gypsies have been a recognised ethnic group for the purposes of British race relations legislation since 1988 and Irish Travellers since 2000 in England and Wales. Over the years, the CRE has supported individuals from these communities in cases of racial discrimination as well as dealing with numerous discriminatory ‘No Travellers’ signs, which seek to deny services to members of Gypsy Traveller communities.
However, the reality is that Gypsies and Travellers continue to face discrimination. Across almost all indices of deprivation and discrimination, Gypsies and Travellers are particularly disadvantaged. This applies in terms of educational attainment, health status, employment profile, quality of housing and contact with the criminal justice system.
Mortality rates are higher than for the general population, life expectancy is significantly lower and in 1999 OFSTED identified Gypsy Traveller children as being the most at risk in the education system.
And, of course, the current planning system and net effect of recent legislation has been detrimental to the way of life of many Gypsies and Travellers.
However, the good news is that we now have a new lever for change. Following the Macpherson Inquiry into the murder of black teenager Stephen Lawrence, the then Home Secretary Jack Straw amended the Race Relations Act 1976. As a result, some 43,000 public authorities-from schools and local authorities to NHS Trusts and police forces-now have a duty to actively promote race equality and good race relations in all their functions.
In order to help them meet this duty, many authorities are required by law to publish a race equality scheme or policy that sets out what they intend to do in order to promote race equality in the way that they make policy or deliver services or employ their staff.
The amended Act became enforceable on 31 May 2002 and the CRE has powers of enforcement to compel public authorities to comply with the legislation.
We are currently reviewing the CRE’s approach to issues that concern Gypsy and Traveller communities and aim to develop a strategy that will outline the Commission’s work in this area for the next three years. We will start by consulting with community representatives and individuals as well as voluntary sector organisations who work with Gypsies and Travellers. We aim to have in place a draft strategy by the autumn for consideration by our Commissioners and for wider consultation." You can report discrimination to your local CRE office.
Pat Niner’s research ‘The Provision and Condition of Local Authority Gypsy/Traveller Sites in England" was published last October. The main points are;
The Economics of Gypsy and Traveller Encampments by Rachel Morris and Luke Clements, Traveller Law Research Unit, Cardiff Law School
Since the Conservative government’s reform of the law and policy relating to accommodation for Travelling People (Gypsies and Travellers) in 1992, there have been no changes in the legislation, despite a major review of housing law and policy commenced by the current Labour government in 2000. A primary motive given for the 1992 legal reforms was financial: that the cost to the public purse of providing sites for Travelling People was unjustifiably high. Yet no study was ever done into the costs of not providing sites.
This book presents the findings of a comprehensive study of the Traveller Law Research Unit at Cardiff Law School of the costs associated with unauthorised encampments. In addition to exploration of the financial costs experienced by local authorities in the UK, both as landowners and as providers of public services, the book also examines the financial, human and social costs suffered by private landowners, police services and Travelling People themselves. The book places these costs in context both by exploring the process of change to law and policy in this field in 1992, and the issues now raised by the ‘Best Value’ regime and other new obligations placed on public bodies by human rights and race relations laws.
At What Cost? Will be invaluable reading for practitioners and policy makers in housing, planning, equality issues, education, welfare and policing at local and national levels. It will also be of interest to social policy and social work academics and students, and to Travelling People themselves.
Paperback £18.99
ISBN 1 86134 423 6
September 2002
Collated by Dave Cannon October 2003
The Gypsy Council (of whom David Essex is Patron) is involved in a wide spectrum of support and liaison work, supporting Gypsy families in planning applications and their fight for decent legal places to live. Read more about the organisation and maybe consider joining.